Statement on Lowering the Voting Age in City Elections
I respect the thoughtful arguments on both sides, especially those made by young residents who want a voice in the laws that shape their lives. But in Rockville’s 2023 advisory referendum, voters rejected lowering the City’s voting age to 16 by a margin of 70 percent to 30 percent. That result was clear, and setting it aside requires a compelling reason.
Supporters point out that majorities once denied voting rights to women and African Americans. But there is an important distinction. Those citizens were excluded because of immutable characteristics; every 16-year-old will, in time, reach the voting age. Government must draw a uniform line somewhere. There will always be exceptional judgment below that line—and poor judgment above it. I heard an impressive 14-year-old speak at a Community Forum. But if individual readiness is the standard, why stop at 16 instead of 15 or 14? Case-by-case eligibility is not workable. A clear threshold treats everyone equally.
Supporters also argue that lowering the age could encourage civic engagement. It might. But we should also consider the incentives it would create for campaigns, candidates, advocacy groups, and special interests seeking access to a concentrated group of new voters.
Political organizations use every lawful opportunity to identify, persuade, and mobilize voters. If thousands of newly eligible voters gather each day in a small number of high schools, those schools will become attractive political targets. They will be seen not only as places for civic education, but also as concentrated pools of prospective votes.
We should be candid about what could follow: requests for access, campaign literature, targeted digital messages, candidate appearances, and organized persuasion. Schools would have to decide who may participate, under what rules, and with what safeguards. Teachers and administrators would be asked to police political activity while preserving neutrality and giving students room to form their own views.
So the question is not whether young people can care deeply about public issues. Many clearly do. The question is whether lowering the voting age would deepen civic learning—or bring the machinery of political campaigns into schools. I want classrooms to remain places where students learn to evaluate political arguments, not another front in the competition for votes.
As the father of a high school senior and another daughter who recently graduated, I also ask: shouldn’t young people have time simply to be young? Teenagers already balance academics, activities, friendships, family responsibilities, and major decisions about their futures. Making them eligible to vote would invite campaigns to compete for their attention and press them to choose sides. Adolescence should still leave room for curiosity, growth, mistakes, fun, and joy. We should prepare young people to exercise the franchise thoughtfully when adulthood arrives—not reshape adolescence around an adult timetable for political engagement.
That brings me to the broader legal threshold. Our laws generally recognize 18 as the beginning of adulthood—the age at which citizens may enter binding contracts, serve on juries, and register for Selective Service. Marylanders under 18 remain minors subject to important restrictions. Driving is often offered as a counterexample, but the full picture points in the other direction.
A Maryland resident generally cannot obtain a provisional driver's license until age 16 years and 6 months. Even then, drivers under 18 remain subject to restrictions on nighttime driving, passengers, and cellphone use. Maryland uses a graduated licensing system that introduces driving privileges in stages rather than all at once. The State recognizes that new drivers may be capable of driving while still requiring additional safeguards and limitations.
Rights and responsibilities should remain connected, especially when it comes to voting. The proposal to require City officeholders to be at least 18 reveals a basic inconsistency. If 16 brings enough maturity, judgment, and experience to choose City leaders, why is it not enough to serve as one?
There is also a practical concern: our election system already faces limits in staff time, funding, and volunteer capacity. Recent elections brought late mail ballots, an omitted residential building, and database errors that left some voters without ballots until the City scrambled to respond. At the same time, a new Board of Supervisors of Elections is still learning its operational and compliance duties.
We saw a recent example just last week, when campaign-finance reports came due and the customary reminder to candidates was not sent. In an email to the Mayor and Council, the Chief Clerk described this as “an unusual year,” noting that “As the Board of Supervisors of Elections (BSE) transitions to new membership, members are becoming familiar with the filing deadlines and report review process.”
I do not say this to criticize either the Clerk or the BSE.
A new Board needs time to learn a complex system. But difficulty with a basic filing reminder should give us pause before we add a much larger administrative project.
Lowering the voting age would involve far more than changing a number in the City Code. The City would have to identify and reach newly eligible 16- and 17-year-olds; create registration procedures and materials; coordinate with schools; explain the change to students and families; modify election systems; train staff and volunteers; and build safeguards for accurate registration and ballot handling. Doing all of that before the 2027 election would leave little time to design, test, publicize, and administer the new process.
That work would fall on a relatively new Board with only three of its five seats filled. The Board already oversees voter registration, candidate eligibility, petitions, campaign-finance compliance, ballots, election publicity, tabulation, certification, and a broader election-code overhaul. Asking it to create a new registration and education program on a compressed timetable would strain oversight and invite preventable mistakes.
Our first obligation is straightforward: make sure every qualified voter receives a ballot, every required notice goes out on time, and every election process is accurate and efficient. We should pass the election ordinance and get the current system right before we expand it.
That brings us back to the referendum. It was advisory, not binding. But a 70 percent to 30 percent vote deserves substantial weight, and overriding the people’s clearly expressed will requires a strong reason. I was one of the 8,665 voters who voted no in 2023. Since then, I have not heard an argument strong enough to outweigh the value of a consistent age threshold, the connection between civic rights and adult responsibilities, and the practical needs of our election system. With the 2027 election approaching—and the broader election code still being implemented—this is the wrong time to add another major burden.
For those reasons, I will vote no on this Charter amendment.